Double Your Weight Loss: The Write Idea


By Shawn McKee
eDiets Contributor

Wouldn’t it be nice if there was something you could do to double your weight loss efforts? According to one of the largest and longest running weight-loss trials ever conducted, there is.Click here for your free diet profile.

What’s this new weight-loss miracle? Is it a drug? A new machine for blasting your abs? A crazy diet where you eat nothing but broccoli?

No. It’s simply your keyboard. Keeping a food diary — recording what you eat throughout the day — can double a person’s weight loss efforts, according to a study conducted by Kaiser Permanente’s Center for Health Research. The study, which was published in the American Journal of Preventive Medicine, found that keeping a daily record can keep your diet on track.

“The more food records people kept, the more weight they lost,” said Kaiser Permanente lead author Jack Hollis Ph.D. “Those who kept daily food records lost twice as much weight as those who kept no records. It seems that the simple act of writing down what you eat encourages people to consume fewer calories.”

The average weight loss over 6 months was roughly 13 pounds, with more than two-thirds of the nearly 1,700 participants losing at least 9 pounds. Those who participated were asked to follow the heart-healthy DASH diet, which is rich in fruits and vegetables, attend weekly support group sessions and exercise for at least 30 minutes a day, as well as tracking what they ate. Participants who used their daily food journals doubled their results.

With more than two-thirds of Americans overweight — and the African American community being particularly susceptible to problems linked to obesity, like heart disease and diabetes — this study was one of the few trials to have a large percentage of African Americans — nearly half of the participants. “If we all just lost 9 pounds, like the majority of people in this study did, our nation would see vast decreases in hypertension, high cholesterol, diabetes, heart disease and stroke,” noted study co-author Victor Stevens, Ph.D., who found in a previous study that losing as little as 5 pounds can reduce the risk of developing high blood pressure by 20 percent.

If it’s as simple as tracking what you eat to lose weight, then fire up the computer. If you eat it, type it in. Food diaries increase accountability and demonstrate where excess calories are coming from according to study participants.

Keeping a food diary doesn’t have to be a formal thing, noted Dr. Keith Bachman in the press release. Bachman, who heads Kaiser Permanente’s Weight Management Initiative, explained that journaling helps people reflect on what they eat, helping them become aware of their habits and, hopefully, changing their behavior.

“Every day I hear patients say they can’t lose weight,” he said. “This study shows that most people can lose weight if they have the right tools and support. And food journaling in conjunction with a weight management program or class is the ideal combination of tools and support.”

What have you eaten today? Have you tried keeping a food journal? Did it work? Let us know and post a comment below.





  • Anonymous

    A journal makes all the difference, but it is boring and a chore to do. It definitely keeps you on the straight and narrow because you don't want to write down "10 a.m.–large brownie." I never lie on the journal.

  • Jocelyne

    I have started logging in whatever I eat since July 7 2009. Today 23 Sep 09 I have already lost 6 Pounds. This was after several attempts before which took me more than one year with no avail. The attempts to loose weight was mainly to exercise on daily basis without watching my calories. In my 20s this used to work very well for me. Now I am 34 and obvioulsy watching my calories, fat and carbohydrates is very essential for loosing weight in addition to a minimum of 30 min excercising on a working day and 2hrs excercising in the weekend. Thanks JH

  • Anonymous

    Keeping a daily food diary has helped my weight management for many years. I use small spiral notebooks, so even on days that I don't control the calories, I'm able to control the quantity—use only one small page per day.

  • Anonymous

    Many a time have I choose not to eat something because I didn't want to have to write the calories down. It also has made me aware of how many calories something I love actually has so then sometimes I only eat half. LOL

  • Anonymous

    I use the "Lose It" app on my iPhone and, WOW! I didn't realize how many calories I was consuming in a day. I never could figure out why I couldn't lose but when I started looking at calories the weight came plummeting off.
    I thought eating a muffin was ok. That is, until I realized a muffin is 400 calories (I'm on a 1414 calorie day diet to lose 2 lbs a week). That's almost a 1/3rd of my daily allotment.
    I don't diet, just count calories. I don't deny myself any food, I just portion it so that I don't go over calories. I started exercising 30 minutes a day.
    It has been 4 months and I have lost 32 pounds. I feel great and I NEVER feel deprived of food.

  • Anonymous

    aloha: have been writing down every
    thing i do, every day: when i take my pills + every thing i eat/ it is ok, but i need to get back on ''hoodia*'' capsules, they really work wonders/i can't do exercises/ in to much pain/ but, atleast i do what i can do: prayers help too: me:

  • karen

    I do keep a daily food journal, and have been doing so since the end of November 2008. I follow the weight watchers diet and have successfully lost an astounding 87lbs.:) I just have 19lbs to go to get to goal.

  • Anonymous

    Itunes has this great program called "Loseit" I don't remember if it is free or not but it has the tools to track down calories and everything. I love it and it's portable.. you don't need internet access. While people think you're choosing a song to listen to on your Ipod you're really tracking your food!

  • Anonymous

    I kept a food journal for the past year. i have lost 60 pounds and have kept it off. Whenever I feel myself starting to "cheat" and eat what I shouldn't i start writing it down, and it is so helpful. I also use a calorie counter to track my calorie intake for the day. I write this in my food journal also. this helps me plan meals and know when to say "no" or "yes" to food.

  • Anonymous

    We agree. Definitely keep a record of your meals for success.

    We lost over 50 pounds and it really keeps you on track.

    Good luck on your journey.

  • chanda rojas

    I am going to try writing everything down. I started working out 6 weeks ago. I excercise in my target heart rate zone 2-4hrs a day, and I have only lost 13lbs.I have a lot to lose…so I hope this will work.

  • Anonymous

    I have started writing down everything I eat/ It makes a big difference when you have to see on paper, everything you have put in your mouth!! I am much more consciensious of my eating habits when I use a food journal. it is one of the best and cheapest ways to lose weight! mp55

  • msp55

    This is one of the cheapest and easiest ways to lose weight. I am much more aware of what I am eating when I have to write it down everyday. What an eye-opener!! I am losing about one poound a week and am very pleased! msp55

  • Anonymous

    Food journals are not new just a nuisance. However, I have an app on my Iphone and I plug in the information as I am eating the meal. It is not perfect so I have started the food journal also. I hope all of this works. I applaud those who have lost tremendous amounts of weight.

  • Anonymous

    I totally think this idea is over-rated. It works at the beginning but I started my weight loss journey 2 years ago, for the first 5 months I lost weight and since then haven't been able to lose hardly anything and I have been keeping a food journal the whole time.

  • Anonymous

    Keeping a diary does help. And your primary care manager may require it for certain types of services. However, where most people fail is when they try to get too technical. You should have to have make it soo complicated that you end up quitting. I keep a food journal, but mostly, if I'm busy, I just mentally track and tabulate as the day goes. At the end of the day I'll write down everything I ate. As long as I have a daily calorie limit, I try not to get too technical. Too much detail tends to lead to disorganization and errors–at least for me.

  • Anonymous

    I have tried keeping a journal of what I eat and it never works for more than a few days. I either forget my journal at home or I am downstairs and the journals upstairs and by the time I get it I have forgotten what I ate or how much I ate or to just write it down. And when it is all on paper what do you do with it. How do you add it all up? If I could just put it down and hit a calculate button and know how many calories I ate that day that would be great. I need help!

  • Anonymous

    Anonymous from MA..
    Over 18 months ago I started keeeping a food log and an exercise log to balance the calories I was consuming against those I was burning. I did this for 3 months as I gradually adapted to a change in lifestyle. I lost 40 pounds over 8 months while going from spinning/cycling to triathlons this past summer. I believe the key is consistency, motivation, and perspiration. Write it down but don't become obsessive when family and friends notice the changes.

  • GirlGeek

    I disagree with this article.

    I have been trying to lose 20 lbs since January of 2008. I was advised by a nutritionist to write down everything I eat, including BLTs (Bites, Licks, Tastes). I have been keeping a food journal since January 1, 2008. I still continue my journaling which includes any BLTs. Have I lost the 20 lbs? Nope. In addition, I spin 3x a week. I take ballet 1x a week. I lift weights. And I walk 2 miles (round trip) every day to and from the train station to my building (I work in the city). I always take the stairs when possible (vs. an elevator or escalator). Furthermore, I bring my meals to work every day which consists of 2 healthy meals and 2 healty snacks (such as almonds and fruit). Journaling my food intake and exercise has done nothing for me in terms of shedding the 20 lbs I am trying to lose.

    Having said all that, this is just my opinion. I am glad that journaling has worked for others. I will continue to journal; however, I would not stand behind any claim that says it guarantees weight loss.

    Thanks for listening.

    Happy New Year!

  • Anonymous

    I think this works exactly like spending cash and spending with credit cards.
    You spend less when you spend cash, because you take the money and count it and see it leaving your pocket which urges you to cut down.
    Same here, you eat less because when you write you don't only write down what you ate but also have a look at what you already ate so far, so you see what has entered your stomach which urges you to cut down

  • ninaprice

    I have to take a lot of meds from the Dr. and I cant lose any weight. is there any help for a person like me.

  • Ketki Thakkar

    Hi, This article assured me that I am on right track. I started keeping record of my intake 8 weeks ago, at that time my weight was 185 pounds and now after 8 weeks I weigh 170. along with keeping record I limited my carbs consumption and increased fruits and water intake. this really helped me. now I am sure this way I will be able to achieve my goal of 135 pounds very soon.

  • http://www.treating-hypertension.com/ Mary

    The idea seems very good to make us aware of what we are actually eating and also serve as a motivation to keep going.

  • HELENA JOUBERT

    IVE GOT THE SAME PROBLEM IF YOU GET AN ANSWER PLEASE LET ME KNOW THANKS HELENA

  • http://www.ediets.com/ eDiets Weight Loss & Fitness

    Hi Ninaprice! Awesome job on the weight loss and sounds like you are losing at a ideal speed – 15 lbs in 8 weeks….that is right on target. Keeping track of your intake, increasing the fluids, watching your carbs – love the increase in fruits (tip…can you include more veggies?) will really help in terms of accountability and staying on course. keep it up. dont forget if you need any help, our eDiets Nutrition team is only an email away… nutrition@ediets.com.
    Keep us posted.
    Pam Ofstein
    eDiets Director of Nutrition

  • http://www.uniquehoodia.com/order-today.php Chloe

    I too keep a diary to lose weight, a friend recommended to me and she lost a lot of weight. At first I kept forgetting to write in but after the first couple of days I was really into it, I have a record of what I eat, the amount of calories at the end of the day and the exercise I have done if any and then if I have had a good week I will give myself a little treat for my hard work however if I have had a bad week – I can usually tell but I will add more exercise to my day to make sure it equals out but I am glad this study has been highlighted, all the effort is worth it.

  • RaphaeleDiets

    Everyone I've ever worked with can attest to the value of food journaling. When one starts to journal their food intake it's a shocking revelation. I often hear “wow I didn't realize I was eating that much.”

  • pt8106

    I have no doubt that keeping a food and activity log helps but I don't believe for one minute that it can double your weight loss. I have been keeping one for over 2 years and I have been in a plateau for over half that time.

  • http://www.ediets.com/ eDiets Weight Loss & Fitness

    You'd be surprised! Just the simple idea of having to be accountable for everything you eat can help curb overeating or mindless snacking. It really does work!

  • Marty

    I do believe in tracking food intake especially. However I also know that “Plateauing” is very common place and requires us to jump start our metabolism again. I read that dieting 5/6 wks and taking 3/7 days off then repeating with another 5/6 weeks dieting and so on is not only a way to keep our metabolism peaked but it also allows us to practice maintainiing our weight when we reach our goal by simply extending our days off. The same way with exercise, it recommends we change routine/type of exercise every couple of weeks. It's helped me, but judge for yourself and read articles and advise on diet plateauing. The source that's helped me lose 35 pounds in 5 months is a competitor to eDiet known as Sparkpeople. They had several articles on this and perhaps eDiet does too.

  • Marlene Vogel

    Lost 35 pounds in 5 months all as a result of recording what I ate and tracking my exercise. I'm a believer.

  • http://www.healthimproves.com/ Patrice

    Must try having journal of what I eat everyday and see if it really works. Thanks for the information. I really need to loss weight now.

  • http://www.weightmanagementbymaryjoy.blogspot.com/ Patrice

    Keeping a journal of what I eat everyday is so easy to do. By this way, we can assess how healthy the food we eat and if we are eating too much.

  • karunakumari

    iam 30 years old. my weight is 65 my height is 5″0 inches.what i have to do to reduce the weight of my body. give the comments to me

  • pt8106

    I have been keeping a journal for the last 2 years. It worked for the first 6 months. It makes no difference later in the weight battle. I still do it so I can turn it into my trainer but see very little benefit to it at this point.

  • Josie Parent

    MY comment is that this is a good theory that you are publicly recommending because seeing is believing!!! When you carefully enter into this food diary what you are really eating and putting inside your body, it will register psychological feelings and intuitions that your brain will try to analyze. I also recommend that they should enter anything that happened on each day that you felt emotionally disturbed or angered about, or depressed about a love problem or family problem. Astrology has been my hobby for 35 years, so I use a calendar that shows the daily position of the MOON every day of the year. The Moon rules our emotions!!! The public would be surprised to learn how much our emotions control our eating habits!!!!

  • Nicole

    I have to keep track of my daily diet for a different reason. I have been in a battle with anorexia and bullimia for about two years. It was at that time that I was hospitalized for anorexia (5' 7″ – 90 lbs.), after my release I was put on meds for depression and weight gain. And that is exactly what I did; laid around depressed and gaining weight. Now, realizing what I have done, I am ready to remedy it. For about 8 monrths I have been trying to diet, without eating, because since I am so used to not eating, I didn't eat and of course I didn't lose any. So, I went back to my hospital days and started keeping track of my daily diet and am doing much better. I can't say for sure how much I weigh, I am not comfortable enough to get on a scale yet, but I do know that my jeans are a size 6, which for me, personally, is unacceptable. I will not have to be hospitalized again, but I will find a happy medium.

  • PameDiets

    Hi Nicole, I commend you for your readiness 'to remedy it'. I imagine it is not easy but the steps that you are taking – keeping track so you can reflect/acknowledge your behaviors – is absolutely going to help you get to that happy medium. My advice is not to be concerned with the scale – focus on personally taking care of yourself – eating and keeping track so you can see your actions. All the rest can wait. You know the importance of eating – no need to preach there ;-). Keep up the positive approach and remember how important YOU are!

  • lisal

    I write down everything I eat, every day, good or bad choices.

  • Maryam Javed

    hello…maryam here…i am 24 years old height is 5.4'' and weight is 64 kgs, iam suffering from a disease policisstic ovaries…my periods are not regular thats y i gain weight, iam really try to lose weight upto 10 to 12 pound but itz not working….what should i eat in this situation so that i can maintain my weight for long..plz do help me.thanx

  • PameDiets

    Hi Maryam,

    With Polycystic Ovary Syndrome (PCOS), it is often recommended to control your carbohydrate intake. In general, you should try to eat a balance of carbohydrates, protein and fat at each meal. For example, having a snack of just fruit would be mostly carbohydrates. But if you add a stick of string cheese to the fruit, you have a more balanced meal that will keep your blood sugars even.

    A food journal will help you identify how much you are eating and where you may need to make changes. If you need help with meal planning, a meal plan like our Living with Diabetes meal plan or Glycemic Impact meal plan both provide consistent carbohydrates (around 40% of your calories) at each meal. This helps you manage your blood sugars.

    In conjunction with eating healthy, adding exercise will help you lose weight and reduce symptoms of PCOS and help prevent long-term health problems. If you are not already active, start slow by taking a walk several times a week or doing a workout video. Just get moving!

    Your doctor may also recommend medicines to help balance your hormones. Follow your doctor’s recommendations for any medications and be sure to follow up to make sure treatment is working. If you are consistent with healthy eating and exercise, you will see results Maryam.

    Good luck!
    eDiets Nutrition

  • maryamahtsham

    Hello…maryam here…thanx for reply,as i told you that i am 24 years old height is 5.4'' and weight is 64 kgs, iam suffering from a disease polycystic ovaries…my periods are not regular thats y i gain weight,
    but as u said in your mail that If i need help with meal planning, a meal plan like our Living with Diabetes meal plan or Glycemic Impact meal plan both provide consistent carbohydrates (around 40% of your calories) at each meal. This helps my manage your blood sugars…. i really do not understand this type of meal which you recommend to me….do you explain this so that i can do use this diet plan… what includes in Diabetes meal plan or in Glycemic impact meal…plz explain and i like to tell you thay doctor recomend me a tablet called GLUCOPHAGE 500mg in 3 times a day, 12 months i take this 3 toimes a day but i do not get proper results so i got disheartened and i left to eat this tablet but since 1 week i start eating this again but now im using this 2 times a day in moring and in evenning, with this i do regular walk and control my diet as wel but i have to lose 12 pounds and want to get out of this disease also so plzz giude me my proper diet plan as im living in Pakistan, thanx alot.take care Byeee

  • Phil

    My wife keeps a daily food log and value for both myself and herself. We started this about 20 months ago. In about 1 year I lost 50 pounds reaching my goal of 170 pounds, at this time my wife Kathy lost 89 pounds and would like to loose about 12 pounds more. Any yes I am sure this has helped up a lot. Without this you would incorrectly gauge you food intake quite frequently.
    Phil, Decatur, IL

  • http://www.ediets.com/ eDiets Weight Loss & Fitness

    Great job, Phil! Congrats on BOTH of your successes! 12 more pounds… We're rooting for her all the way!

  • Jreisner

    see your doctor. Glucophage is for diabetes, not for weight loss. It helps regulate insulin. You should not start or stop taking it without doctor's aoproval.

  • Levi Hewitt099

    hi

Lose 10 lbs. in 5 Weeks!
Find the perfect plan for you...
Start FREE eDiets Profile:
I want to:
Get A Custom Plan

Disclaimer: The information provided is intended for your knowledge only and is not a substitute for professional medical advice or treatment for specific medical conditions. Please talk with your healthcare provider regarding any questions or concerns you may have regarding your condition.