Top 5 “Bad” Foods — and Healthy Substitutes

Keywords: , ,

By eDiets Staff

Oops, I did it again… If you sing that song whenever you eat a certain food, consider it a “trigger” food. Translation: Don’t derail your diet goals by eating foods you have a history of overeating.

Easier said than done? Here are the three steps to managing those not-so-healthy foods:

1. Recognize your triggers. For me, it’s always been ice cream. I would buy a carton of fudge vanilla swirl, for example, planning to limit myself to just a half cup for dessert. I’d dig into the creamy mixture, have “just a taste” — and all my plans went into the trash. Along with the empty half-gallon carton of ice cream. Inevitably, I felt sick the next day and mad at myself for giving in. I’d try setting up rules (“I’ll only eat ice cream on weekends,” or “I’ll only eat vanilla ice cream — that’s safe and boring”), but those rules were a game of deception that resulted only in weight gained.

2. Accept which ones are “danger zone” foods. If you are unable to limit yourself to a single serving, it’s a “red light” food for you.

3. After you recognize your trigger foods, discover safe healthy foods substitutes. And for help with this critical third step, check out my list below!


Trigger Food #1: Ice Cream
Is ice cream one of your trigger foods? Then keep those half-gallon containers out of your house. Instead, consider one of these healthy foods options:

– Stop eating ice cream. Period. Instead, call around to local frozen yogurt shops until you find one that serves sugar-free, low-calorie frozen yogurt. Check to make sure that it’s really low-calorie (for example, one of the yogurt cafes in my hometown has frozen yogurt that is 10 calories per ounce). Rather than take it home, order a small serving at the cafe, and enjoy it there. — Buy pre-portioned, sugar-free frozen treats, such as sugar-free Fudgsicles. Just 40 calories each, with calcium, protein and no sugar, these individually-wrapped chocolate fudge frozen treats are one of my favorite healthy foods for after-dinner desserts.


Trigger Food #2: Baked Potatoes
I used to consider myself virtuous for ordering a baked potato instead of French fries at a restaurant. Of course, I always opted for the variety stuffed with melted cheese and butter and topped with sour cream. And I couldn’t understand why I didn’t lose weight. Answer: Those enormous potatoes served in restaurants actually are the equivalent of two to four servings. Add in those high-calorie, high-fat extras like cheese, butter and sour cream, and you’re looking at a so-called side course that can have more calories and fat than you’ve budgeted for your entire dinner!

Healthy foods substitutes:

– Steamed vegetables. Skip the butter and cheese topping and sprinkle on some herbs. — A baked potato or yam that you share with a friend — and substitute plain yogurt for that fattening topping.


Trigger Food #3: Pizza
“I’m just going to have one piece,” you promise yourself. Then the delivery person arrives at your front door. You open up the box and that fragrance wafts through the room. One piece leads to another… and then of course there’s the garlic bread on the side. Before you know it, your diet is out the door along with the empty pizza box container.

Healthy foods substitute:

– A whole-grain English muffin half. Top with fat-free or low-fat mozzarella cheese and tomato sauce mixed with herbs, and put under the broiler until the cheese melts. You’ve got the flavor of pizza without the calories and fat!


Trigger Food #4: Pie
Yes, I know, apple pie is as traditional as baseball. And it counts as a fruit serving, right? Hah! When you mix sugar and butter with those apples, then make that crust with lard and more sugar, and top the whole conglomeration off with whipped cream or extra-rich vanilla ice cream, you’re creating a recipe for diet trouble.

Healthy foods substitutes:

– One-half cup of unsweetened applesauce mixed with a half-cup of sugar-free vanilla yogurt and 1/2 teaspoon of cinnamon. — A plain baked apple sprinkled with cinnamon and a packet of sugar-free sweetener, such as Splenda or Equal.


Trigger Food #5: Cheese
One ounce of cheese is only about the size of a domino — and can pack as much as 130 calories. Consider just how much cheese you can tuck away for a snack. Add on the calories in the accompanying crackers. And you’ve just consumed more calories in your supposedly innocent snack than you might have allotted for a half-day of food on your diet!

Healthy foods substitute:

– Individually pre-packaged “light” or fat-free cheese, such as individually wrapped low-fat string cheese.

Do you have any healthy foods you eat when you’re craving something bad? Help us out and share your ideas!





  • Anonymous

    If you love Ice Cream – here is a good alternative that is healthy. It is not calorie free but is healthy nevertheless.

    I have a champion juicer and use that but other juicers may well work with this too.

    Freeze Strawberries. Freeze 1 inch slices of bananas (similar to size of strawberries.) Put through the juicer frozen with the blank rather than the screen. This homogenizes the fruit. I put 1 strawberry, 1 piece of banana, 1 strawberry, 1 piece of banana, etc. and out of the spout comes a wonderful frozen strawberry-banana confection that is pure fruit and tastes and has the consistency of ice cream. I have done this for folks who are not "health freaks" and they have been very impressed. I don't use the banana by itself as it is very, very sweet. I like it mixed with strawberry. You can even use frozen strawberries from the grocery store when fresh are not available to freeze. (Fresh are usually less expensive when in season so that is why I use Fresh.)
    I have not tried alot of other fruits but imagine they will work well too. It is a great alternative to ice cream and helps you get your daily servings of fruit. (Be careful not to overdo the banana as they have a lot of calories. But they are healthier than the ice cream!!)

  • Anonymous

    Bring on the Splenda!!! :) Oh, and the aspartame. No sugar for me please.

  • Anonymous

    Vita Tops…LOVE them…only 100 calories and FULL of fiber

  • Kathie

    Chocolate is my downfall. I can't even bring it in the house. But, lately I've discovered 70% and 85% Lindt dark chocolate. The bars are a little bitter, but when I need a chocolate fix, I break off a square and treat myself. To my surprise, I've noticed that the bar can sit there for a week sometimes without me even thinking about it. Whereas,if it were a regular chocolate bar, it would be gone in 2 seconds flat. The dark chocolate has to be at least 70% to work..otherwise there's too much sweet and fat. It gives me a chocolate fix and, supposedly, dark chocolate is good for you!

  • Beth

    Any of the Quaker Rice Cakes help me when I have a craving for something bad. They have so many different flavors and can cure the sweet or salty craving. They are low in fat and calories and very delicious!

  • http://profiles.yahoo.com/u/AX6LRPKDCHCEYBFVZUGUYWJQAQ chipndip

    Hi! A couple of months ago I stopped eating cereal, eggs, bacon, bagals and other traditional breakfast foods. My daughter enjoys a glass of Carnation Instant Breakfast in the morning before school because its quick and easy. So I thought I'd give it a try with a twist. Fat Free frozen yogurt (1/2 cup), a serving size of Carnation Instant Breakfast and a 1/4 cup of 1% milk in the blender is a great breakfast and it lasts 'til lunch! You can use vanilla yogurt, vanilla Carnation Instant Breakfast and add some of your favorite fruit for some extra flavor. It also makes great homemade cream popsicles for an afternoon snack or evening desert. Kids love them, too!
    Lisa

  • Lisa

    Another trigger food for me is garlic. After a “garlicy” meal I will find myself craving sweets. So I have been trying to carry sugar free mints or gum for after one of those meals. It helps and I am sure the ones I talk to after lunch are very appreciative for the minty breath rather than the garlic!

  • Lory

    I also use dark chocolate (Lindt or other brands with at least 70% cocao. I think the 855 is just too bitter. One square will satisfy me, but I almost have one square a day. I loved Coco Via, but can't find in the stores anymore or Atkin's dark choc pretzels. If you know where I can still purchase, LMK. Thanks, Lory

  • PameDiets

    Hi Lory, thanks for posting. I include a piece of chocolate daily as well. Love it and has some good health benefits. As for locating Coco Via…I have had a hard time as well locally. Online tough too…but if you find chocolate that you enjoy with a high % of cocoa as you noted….that is the key. If I can find it will be sure to post. Pam – eDiets Nutrition Director

  • Mommy

    Thank you!

  • Marlene

    Here's a tasty snack that makes a nice desert after dinner: natural chunky apple sauce from Trader Joe's topped off with a controlled amount of Sun Nut Butter (sunflower butter). It's healthy, has lower fat than peanut butter and the apples are natural and sugar-free. It's a great combo.

  • Candice

    I agree with Kathie below, Chocolate, especially milk chocolate is a huge trigger food for me. Might even be in the danger zone, so I've figured out if I buy dark chocolate (also lindt), it's a bit more bitter, and I'm less likely to eat as much of it. I like it flavoured with orange so it's not quite so sharp on the tastebuds.

  • Lisa

    Laughing Cow Light Cheese and 3 Triscuits – delicious and much healthier than a couple chunks of regular cheese and lots of crackers!

  • J3n Pearson

    That is a tasty snack for sure, and very healthy. Trader Joes has some amazing products! One thing to note- just because something is natural does not mean it is sugar free- apples do indeed contain natural sugar- not much, and certainly not the processed kind- but they do have some. According to nutrition websites, one small apple is ~77 calories with 15 grams of sugar, and 4 of fibre.

  • Mandapanda

    Lite chocolate soy milk is rich and thick and satisfies my chocolate cravings for only 90 calories a serving, plus it is rich in healthy protein! And when I am craving lasagna I buy the Classic Lasagna from Smart Ones, because it only has 300 calories but still manages to be delicious. Another alternative to cheese and crackers would be hummus and low-sodium, whole wheat crackers. There is a big variety in flavors of hummus and it is better for you than cheese but goes well with crackers and whole-grain english muffins as a filling, tasty, healthy snack!

  • Joann

    I have found Carrot slices… they are crinkle cut slices of carrots. I don't know why, but they taste better than the little carrots. they are like picking on chips, and you can eat them with no guilt ! they are just thin slices of big carrots… and they are crisp, and they are good. Also I do use the butter spray, and the salad sprays. These tricks are really working for me !

  • Mrobinson

    My downfall is potato chips — what do you recommend as a substitute (if there IS one!)?

  • Martynutt

    helio fellow weight concious people for a swet lil crunch try frozen grapes, also when you are craving something sweet it is usualy you need something with a lil sour try dill pickles just helped me when i lost 160 lbs and have had it off for 33 years ago !!!!!! you cn achieve any weight goal if you have a realistic goal
    good eating!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • http://www.ediets.com/ eDiets Weight Loss & Fitness

    Wow! That is great, Martynutt! Losing 160 pounds AND keeping it off for 33 years… HUGE CONGRATS!

    You advice is much appreciated by everyone, we're sure. It's always great to hear what works from someone who's had great success!

  • http://www.ediets.com/ eDiets Weight Loss & Fitness

    Great tip, Joann!

  • http://www.ediets.com/ eDiets Weight Loss & Fitness

    Hummus is a great choice. We love it!

  • PameDiets

    Hi Mrobinson! good question. Hard to pass on chips sometimes or only have one or two! For me, I usually sub them out for 'baked chips/baked tortilla chips' if I am looking for a crunchy salty type fix; or other suggestions are mixed snack (whole grain cereal, pretzels, nuts) or popcorn (one of my favorites), few whole grain crackers……Hope that helps. Just remember portion counts in all foods – that is the tricky part. ;-)

  • rd

    I had a huge salt craving last night and the Tostitos were calling me from the cupboard… but I bypassed them and opted for sliced cucumber with a little salt. I felt better about my choice but still got to have a little pig-out while watching my favorite shows!

  • Jessica

    I have a really bad habit of eating while I'm working at my computer and since I work from home, no one is here to tell me I can't. Recently, a friend told me what she does so she feels like she's reaching into that bag of potato chips, but she's not packing on the calories and fat. I tried it and I absolutely LOVE it.

    Get a box of Multi-Grain Cheerios. One serving is 1 cup. Get zippered sandwich baggies and put a cup of the Cheerios in each one. When you get ready to eat one, put a few drops of olive oil and a little bit of your favorite seasonings. If I have a sweet craving, I use a pack of Splenda and some Cinnamon. For a salty craving I use garlic powder, celery powder, and onion powder.

    This way, you have a bag of something to keep reaching your hand into and you have a crunchy, and healthier snack alternative than the chips.

    Try it. It's really good. Oh, and my mom uses Wheat Chex instead of Multi-Grain Cheerios which works great too. Not sure of the serving size on the Wheat Chex though.

  • denee

    hi I sometimes buy veggie thin crackers you get 100 calories for every 13 you eat and that is usually enough to satisfy your craving.. hope this works for you

  • MARTYNUTT

    GOOD FOR YOU KEEP IT UP IT IS A MIND GAME AS FOR FOOD WE PLAY WITH YOU CAN ACHIEVE ANYTHING AND THIN TASTE SWEETER THAN ANYTHING THAT PASSED THOUGH OUR MOUTHS DOWN TO OUR HIPS!!!! A MOTTO TO GO BY IT HELPED ME !!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • PameDiets

    Jessica, love the suggestions! I know when i am working from home much more difficult to not take a break, grab something, etc. The portioned out bags of cheerios and with the flavorings are a perfect idea. I do that with cereal, little bit of nuts and even maybe some dried fruit (in a baggie) if i am looking for something sweet. thanks for the suggestions!

  • RaphaeleDiets

    Martynutt – Wow! 160 pounds and you've kept it off for 33 years. Simply astounding. I'm giving you a standing ovation!

  • Starr_uno

    The veggies will not satisfy my potato taste. When I'm craving chips (my weakness), I have a few Baked Chips…the garden veggies are pretty good.

    When I want something sweet,I have the Mini Rice Cakes…..Caramel Corn

Lose 10 lbs. in 5 Weeks!
Find the perfect plan for you...
Start FREE eDiets Profile:
I want to:
Get A Custom Plan

Disclaimer: The information provided is intended for your knowledge only and is not a substitute for professional medical advice or treatment for specific medical conditions. Please talk with your healthcare provider regarding any questions or concerns you may have regarding your condition.