Obesity More Dangerous Than Smoking


By Shawn McKee
eDiets Contributor

Smoking has long been considered the greatest modifiable risk factor affecting longevity and quality of life, but it looks like obesity may now be an even greater threat to the health of Americans.

In the the American Journal of Preventive Medicine, researchers from Columbia University and The City College of New York calculate that the quality of life and years lost due to obesity are now equal to or greater than those lost due to smoking.

Both of these modifiable risk factors affect how someone feels on a day-to-day basis, as well as their overall lifespan. While smoking has a larger impact on deaths, obesity has a greater impact on illness and quality of life.

From 1993-2008 the Behavioral Risk Factor Surveillance System (BRFSS), the largest on-going state-based health survey of the U.S., conducted interviews of more than 3.5 million people. The survey asked questions about recent health problems and overall physical and mental health, then the authors converted this data into healthy days lost to smoking and obesity.

Obesity is beginning to leave a larger footprint on the American population because the number of smokers declined, while the number of obese Americans increased. Over the past 15 years, the number of adult smokers in the US has dropped 18.5 percent, while the proportion of obese Americans increased by 85 percent, according to the report.

Smoking tobacco is recognized as the leading cause of lung cancer, according to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC). In the U.S., 90 percent of lung cancer deaths in men — and 80 percent in women — are due to smoking.

People who smoke are 10 to 20 more times likely to get lung cancer than those who do not smoke, reports the CDC. Smoking also increases the risk of other cancers, as well as heart disease, stroke and emphysema.

With the well-publicized dangers of smoking, it is no surprise we are seeing the number of smokers decline in this country. However, with the widespread increase in obesity, America is now facing a new health crisis.

Carrying a lot of extra weight also takes its toll on a person’s body and can cause a myriad of health problems. Obesity increases risk for heart disease, diabetes, several forms of cancer, high blood pressure, stroke, sleep apnea and osteoarthritis, according to a report by the CDC.

In a 2008 report, the CDC found that 33.8 percent of American adults are obese (32.2 percent men, 35.5 percent women), while the number of US smokers fell to 20.6 percent.

Quitting smoking is a good start to improving quality and length of life, but reducing weight is fast becoming just as crucial. It took decades for Americans to realize the dangers of tobacco smoke, but hopefully we can make the learning curve a little faster on the health risks of obesity — before this problem grows out of control.





  • http://www.erikorganic.com/dining-room/dining-room-table.shtml dining room table

    Both are dangerous. What one must do is to avoid both and everything will be okay. Live healthy.

  • http://www.blogger.com/profile/18421528253671440239 Cindy, aka Tru

    Yeah, okay…but what if you are having difficulty with both?? Which should you tackle first? I've found doing both at the same is very difficult at best.

  • Anonymous

    What if you are dealing with both though? Which one should you deal with first? I stopped smoking, and gained a lot of weight, then pick up smoking again, and I've lost 30 pounds in the last 9 months. Was told by a doctor if I quit cold turkey, which I had done before, I'd more than likely gain all the weight I've lost back. Been obese most of my life, and a smoker on/off for the last 20 or so years.

  • Anonymous

    It really IIIS difficult! But we only have one life. And we now know what to do to make it long and enjoyable.

    Just discipline yourself. It is your right hand (sometimes left hand) which pushes a cigarette or unnecessary food into your mouth.

    Your hand, driven by your mind, and voluntarily!

  • http://www.blogger.com/profile/15059091378622111873 Situ tata

    Alcohol or Tobacco or Food !!!!

    Behind every action …there is a desire ….prompted by an un-controlled or agitated mind …because of a feed back from Intellect which is acting like a RAM of an event which was a "pleasure"

    So only a calm & serene mind can establish "Control" …please try meditation …H.R.SITARAM

  • Anonymous

    The health risks due to obesity should have been publicized years ago, just as the effects of smoking were. Rather than focusing on physical appearance, the nutrition industry should have focused on health and quality of life. The connection between fast food and obesity and middle age and obesity
    should have been addressed by the Surgeon General, the American Heart Association, the Diabetes Association and others.

  • Anonymous

    I wasn't overweight until I quit smoking and with them stating that the # of smokers has went down while obesity is going up well maybe they should take a harder look at that. MAKES SENSE RIGHT?

  • Anonymous

    devildog147 I DID BOTH THINGS,ISTOPED SMOKING FRIST THEN I HAD THE HARDEST TIME OF MY LIFE WITH OBESITY BUT I'M STARTING TO SEE THE LIGHT, AT THE END OF THE TUNNEL.YOU CAN DO IT.HAVE FATH AND DONT GIVE UP.IT'S HARD WORK BUT IT CAN BE DONE.

  • Anonymous

    stop making excuses. finish your last pack and put the twinkie down.

  • annika

    The trick is this: while smoking does indeed increase the basic metabolic rate (the body has to work harder to detox your body from the over thousand toxins in cigarettes!, the primary reason why we gain weight when we stop smoking is actually due to a psychological stoop. Most people make the mistake of eating more once they stop smoking because the hand is used to putting something to the mouth and being busied…to substitute…we keep that hand-to-mouth habit and just fill the hand with food instead of the cigarette.
    Once we get something other to busy us, such as ports or something to busy the hands…we can curb and eventually break that habit. There is though scientific evidence that proves cigarette smoke kills the taste buds and smothers the full-flavor, that, which gives us the joy of eating…once we stop smoking, those taste buds liven up again and everything starts to taste much more intense…
    I think if we keep that in mind and ask ourselves "whose boss?!", we can surely break both smoking and overeating habits…
    Cheers!

  • Anonymous

    There is a MAJOR diference:
    One can stop smoking and NEVER smoke again,
    One can only decrease and change what one eats, but eating MUST continue

  • dr.kac

    All change begins in the mind. Make up your mind that you are worth the change and begin to make your choices for life one step ay a time. There are many helpful, free programs online that can assist you in your path. Please take this article to heart and know that you have the power to change your life for the good.

  • Anonymous

    An estimated 1 Billion people will die from smoking related illnesses within the next century if they do not make a major change. Being over-weight is a huge issue, but its also very American due to over indulgence. Smoking by far outweighs the risks of being overweight. You shouldn't publish articles to merely promote your weight-loss programs.

  • Cindy Lynn

    @Cindy aka Tru

    I smoked for 23 years and quit successfully. I'm now working on my obesity problem. If I hadn't of quit smoking I would NEVER be able to exercise while changing my diet which is a CRUCIAL part of getting healhy.
    It can be done, and you'll feel so much better!! Best of luck, you Can do it =)

  • Anonymous

    Lose weight first. I've lost 130 pounds (in less than 2 years) and smoked the whole way. I've smoked for 5 years. I'm not HAPPY or PROUD to be a smoker, but now that my weight is manageable and I'm more interested in higher-intensity workouts, quitting seems like the next logical step to take. PLUS, I've modified my behavior irrevocably, so I know that even without smoking, I'd never eat the way I used to again. So I say lose weight to make it manageable, then quit, then finish the process! It's working for me!

  • Anonymous

    Gave up smoking twenty years ago, lost the extra weight two years ago.
    Nothing is easy, mind over matter.
    Never wanted to smoke after giving it up.

Lose 10 lbs. in 5 Weeks!
Find the perfect plan for you...
Start FREE eDiets Profile:
I want to:
Get A Custom Plan

Disclaimer: The information provided is intended for your knowledge only and is not a substitute for professional medical advice or treatment for specific medical conditions. Please talk with your healthcare provider regarding any questions or concerns you may have regarding your condition.