Fake vs. Real Deal: A Brand-New Bag?


By Chandra Coleman-Ross
eDiets Contributor

Louis, Christian, Chloe, Hermes, Prada! How are you, darlings? If you are a purse fanatic, you know these names well. These are the luxury handbags that make many of us women swoon, yet not all of us can buy. In recent years, counterfeit versions of these have popped up everywhere — from the streets of New York City to the Spanish Steps in Rome — cheap versions for a quarter of the retail price. Is this right? Should you buy a fake bag?

We’re talking serious money. Bags by these designers typically sell for between $800 and $1,200. This is for normal-sized bag — totes or “oversized” purses go up in price. The crème de la crème is the coveted Birkin bag by Hermes, which for certain styles, has a perpetual waiting list. These bags start at $6,000 and can go up to $75,000. That’s right. A quick search on eBay revealed the asking price for a Birkin was $37,500. So all of sudden, buying a fake doesn’t seem so crazy, right?

Out of the five or so bags I own, one is fake. I bought it in London and somehow thought having bought it in Europe it would seem less fake. But to tell you the truth, I hardly use it; I almost feel guilty parading it around. I have come to the conclusion that I would rather save my money and buy the real deal.

Although luxury companies charge really ridiculous prices for their handbags (not to mention clothes, shoes, sunglasses, etc.), it’s because they aren’t meant for everyone. The quality of the materials and the time that goes into making them sets them apart; they come in limited editions and/or only a certain number of bags are created every year (hence the waiting list for the Birkin).

Reasons you may not want to buy a fake:

–It is illegal. You are a willing participant of the black market when you buy anything that is counterfeit. –Labor: Think about who produces these bags — not little old ladies in Italy (who really do hand sew every Bottega Venetta purse), but probably child laborers in sweatshops. –Exclusivity: It lessens the exclusivity of the item when all of a sudden anyone can have one.

How to Spot a Fake
If you don’t want to buy a fake, learn how to spot one. This goes for online buying as well.

–Do not buy from anyone in China or Hong Kong. These are the countries where so many of the fakes are made, so it’s most likely that’s what they’re selling.
–If it sounds too good to be true, then it probably is. A bag that retails for $1,000 and is selling for $500 is not real.
–When online, ask the seller for close-up pictures of details like stitching and leather quality if they are not apparent.
–Look for “Made in Italy” or wherever the brand is from (Balenciaga bags are made in Paris, for example), usually displayed on the inside on a plaque. If it is missing, or it says “Made in China,” do not buy.
–Know your seller. If you’re on eBay, for example, look for seller feedback. If there isn’t any available, or it’s negative, don’t buy from this person.
–Know the real deal. Go into a boutique or store like Neiman Marcus or Saks and look at and touch a real bag so you’re familiar with it.

If you want to buy online, there are sites like NetAPorter.com and ELuxury.com that are guaranteed authentic.

Rent a Purse!
Guys get to rent tuxedos — why shouldn’t women be able to rent purses? For a monthly fee, you can choose the bag of your dreams and “own” it for a certain amount of time, return it and get a new one! Think Netflix for handbags. What a brilliant idea. Check out BagBorrowOrSteal.com or FromBagsToRiches.com.

Have you ever used one of these Web sites to “borrow” a bag? Let us know how it went! Comment below…

We think you’d also like these posts:
All-Natural Breast Lift
Power of Persuasion: Food or Sex?
Stars: Just Like Us?

Chandra Coleman-Ross has spent the past five years working at Internet companies and writing about fashion, health and entertainment among other topics. She is recently married and lives in Miami.





  • http://www.blogger.com/profile/13978588812697572883 Ria

    Manufacturers really insult our intelligence by offering bags for anything over $100.00. You have to be an idiot to pay more for your handbag than you do for your car. Then, we have, “Rent a Bag”? How shallow can you get. Women of the world, wake up and smell the coffee!

  • http://www.blogger.com/profile/09987371816105724988 veronica_artus

    What planet are you on???
    What makes you think that they
    aren’t marketing to you that
    you need this purse to put
    that extra money in their pocket..
    Consider this: Put that extra
    money in your pocket:
    1. education
    2. travel
    3. retirement
    4. put money away for a rainy day
    like if you get laid off.
    And, do you really think they
    they don’t use cheap labor??

  • http://www.blogger.com/profile/05246708591268060871 sbow00

    This part is my favorite explanation for not buying a fake “Exclusivity: It lessens the exclusivity of the item when all of a sudden anyone can have one.” Exclusivitiy = Status. Isn’t this what it’s all about? It’s okay for others to buy fakes because it just makes you that much better than the people who can’t afford the real thing, right? I’m disappointed eDiets would actually have a story about why to buy a $6,000 bag! Save the story for Vouge.

  • http://www.blogger.com/profile/08069826163314087285 Laurie

    Does that fake bag you never use make you feel like one of “us” regular people? There are “look-a-like” handbags from reputable retailers (try http://www.fashionknockoffs.com) for under $50, everyone knows these bags are just for the fun of it… not to make some statement that says “I wasted $800 on a handbags” There are so many important issues in the world today, lets not be so shallow ladies!

  • http://www.blogger.com/profile/11614770457815226174 superhotwife

    You are a fool if you gamble that the bag on ebay is real. There are schools just to train resale stores (in China & Japan too!) on all the intricate details to detect fakes.Do you actually think a close up photo will be proof.I really wish if you choose to print an article that you would go as far as to include ALL that the counterfit market supports as well as child labor, etc. It's WRONG & it's STEALING.

  • http://www.blogger.com/profile/10233658220056393221 Saira

    If there’s one thing that I hate, it’s when people parade around with fake Louis Vuitton purses (and you can generally tell that they’re fake by what the rest of the person’s outfit is like) and those Chanel t-shirts. As if Chanel would ever make t-shirts with their logo and sell them to the general public. The way I see if, if you can’t afford it, don’t buy the knockoff. While I agree that there are a lot of very expensive handbags out there, there are still brands that are much cheaper than high end couture ones. Try Coach, for example. Very in style in Canada, and relatively affordable. Not to mention, you can still buy a regular purse and spruce it up a bit with a small designer scarf tied around the handles. It looks cute!

    When I graduated from high school, I had quite a bit of money saved up from the time in my life when I hated shopping, and I bought an authentic Dior purse. I absolutely love it, and I don’t regret buying it at all.

    I also agree with paying for the craftsmanship.. it’s nice to know that what you bought is hand made and very sturdy. It’s awful to give those sweat shops more money to keep them running when poor children are getting paid next to nothing in horrible conditions for their work.

  • Lisa

    It’s actually quite sad that e-diets would consider printing this article. Come into the “real” world and realize that the women of today are not this shallow and know they are worth so much more than to base their status on the accessories they own. In today’s economy, us women are putting our money into much more worthy causes: education, world issues, planning for our children’s future, etc. Is it any wonder why many people don’t read the couture mags?

  • Anonymous

    There was an article in a magazine recently that stated other reasons not to buy knock offs: the money made supports terrorist groups!!! Also children do make the bags in sweatshops (they had pics of children chained to their work tables with broken legs)!! Who would ever want to support this?!

  • Anonymous

    I have to agree. The tone of this article is very snotty and I’m very surprised that eDiets ran it. It’s more suited for Vogue or somewhere snotty where the “little people” who have bills to pay wouldn’t ever be able to spend $800 on a PURSE let alone $75,000

    I definitely wanted to read the article, but this article and its condescending tone doesn’t belong on a site dedicated to helping women feel better about themselves. This just reiterates what the fashion world is constantly saying: if you’re not thin, rich and beautiful, you are not one of us.

    Shame, eDiets.

  • Anonymous

    What the heck do you think that an average person makes a year? Have you lost your mind spenidng more than 30bucks on a bag that you use just to show off ? If it is for real heavy lifting and regular use, I can go as high as 50-75$ and I make very very good money.
    I would rather spend that money on taking a usefull class or even donate to some nice charity like Red cross to make me feel really good. Never on useless show off bags or shoes…..especially in this economy publishing such articles is outrageous and pure nonsense.I strongly believe that I dont need to impress any one just by showing off expensive stuff as along as I am happy with what I have. I dont pump my hard earned money to any brand name manufacturers who charge outrageous money for silly and useless things and make them even richer.

  • pinkheart

    it’s probably for the best that the materialistic and shallow twits carry these expensive bags. that way you can identify them from a distance, and not waste your time talking to them.

  • Anonymous

    Last year, at 44 years of age, I bought my first expensive purse ($500 by Coach). I normally would have never spent so much money on an accessory, but it was exactly the shape and color I had been search for for the last two years. I used two gift cards and actually only spent $150 of my own money out of pocket. I am here to tell you that I would never do it again. Because it was an extravagant purchase for me, I was constantly stressed out that someone was going to scratch it while I was walking down the street, I was going to accidently write on it while grocery shopping, or some other atrocity would befall the precious bag. I was actually glad when the season ended and I could change purses to a deal I got at Fred Meyer at 40% off. Finally I could relax! I still love that Coach purse, but I’ll never spend that much money on a purse ever again, much to the chagrin of my friend the buyer at Nordstrom who regularly drops $1,500 on purses. PLEASE!

  • Anonymous

    IF I HAVE THE MONEY TO BUY IT,ILL BUY IT. I'M NOT GOING TO DEPRIVE MYSELF OF SOMETHING IF I "CAN" AFFORD IT. I HAVE A SAVINGS, 401K, STOCKS ETC… I MANAGE MY MONEY VERY WELL SO I CAN AND WILL REWARD MYSELF AS NEEDED. I USUALLY SEARCH FOR A BARGAIN BUT OCCASIONALLY IVE SPLURGED. NO BIG DEAL. I EARNED MY MONEY …"NOT YOU". IF SOMEONE WERE TO JUDGE ME AS BEING SHALLOW, I REALLY WOULDN'T CARE. THE WOULD SIMPLY CLASSIFY THEM AS ENVIOUS HATER AND MOVE ON. IF "MY PURSE" BOTHERS YOU, THEN YOU REALLY DO HAVE ISSUES!IT PERSONALLY DOESN'T AND WILL NOT AFFECT ME;o)

  • ferah_tan

    There are pros and cons to buying designer bags (or any other item actually). You do get good quality, because the material and workmanship is highly tested etc. On the other hand that workmanship and material does not reflect the whole price – at least 60% of the price is for the branding: the designers name of a little label, the advertising etc. So what at least 60% of your money goes into your belief that the glamour of the brand will rub off on you. And, although some are produced by "sweet little old ladies in Rome", some of those same bags are also produced in sweatshops.
    Personally; I don't place that much importance on the brand name being "real" – if I like it, I will get it and the cheaper the better.

  • Anonymous

    Such a rediculous article. I think we should all put a ban on ourselves not to buy such expensive items, when we see most of the world population is dieing of hunger. I think it is our duty to banish these products.

  • Penni

    I am sitting here and I don't even know what to say. This article has hurt me to the soul.

    I believe the author is trying to tell us why to buy real and not fake but it has come off as an advertisement on why we should need or should want an overpriced, unnecessary, glamor item.

    I would say, save your money. Start an organic garden and help your community clean up this world.

    When was this article actually written? Is it recycled from the 80's? It is hard for me to believe someone wrote this in 2009 with our economy the way it is.

  • http://www.blogger.com/profile/04390352533146841449 SugunaS

    well well i agree with wat other readers have said.. the writer,you should have kept in mind the feelings of all woman and not only the bag lovers.. perhaps you are a branded lover person, so you wrote it in with your experiance.. it's not wrong.. but it hurts the others…

    anyway… all i can say is, the tips given to identify a real n the fake is not so impresive.. you should have work out more on it.. the tips you gave , is something all of us knew already and fake bags these days are so so real, u can hardly see the differences.. so you can improve on that area..
    Even i am not a bag lover and not a branded person.. still i would like to learn how to distinguish the fake n real.

    ediets have tought me a lot of things .. so i am looking forward for a improved version on this topic.. all the best ;)

  • http://www.blogger.com/profile/14648714717917707286 msrccl

    I don't agree with "renting" a bag. If you are going to rent one and then another, why not just save up your money and BUY the thing..the one you REALLY want. It's the same as renting a home or owning one – your money when renting goes out the window with nothing to show for it… Just BUY, ladies!!

  • michellemybelle

    i agree. i got hooked buying designer bags because of my friends who would talk about the brands non-stop, and now i have to buy just to keep up with them. today i somehow regret the 'bondage' that these materialistic tendencies have over me. aside from the fact that i have been spending good amounts of money on bags which could otherwise have helped so many other worthy causes, i always have this nagging feeling of having to keep with competition, and it doesn't feel good. sometimes i wish i could go back to those good old days when my bags and shoes were all from thrift stores and from dept. stores, and there was nothing wrong at all with that. all told, i really think i have to find some new friends fast.

  • barbequegirl

    yes, granted, these high-end designer bags are of superior quality. BUT the quality also has its LIMITS. have you ever seen old LV bags with the monogram canvas? the leather handles acquire a certain darkness after how many uses, and thereafter becomes just plain black. i'm not kidding! the sweat from your palms also rubs off on the handles (this also goes for the damier azur line), making it darker and dirtier to look at. and you have to be extra fastidious with keeping the bags free from moisture, molds, sticky hands, ballpens, dirty grocery push carts, ice cream, etc. etc.

  • Cristi

    Hi Chandra,
    Just saw your article about Thierry Mas.. Do you still go to Evan? He's not there and my eyebrows NEED him. He's the only person in Miami I trust!
    Let me know pleaseeee!
    Thanks,
    Cristi
    cristiravelo@gmail.com

Lose 10 lbs. in 5 Weeks!
Find the perfect plan for you...
Start FREE eDiets Profile:
I want to:
Get A Custom Plan

Disclaimer: The information provided is intended for your knowledge only and is not a substitute for professional medical advice or treatment for specific medical conditions. Please talk with your healthcare provider regarding any questions or concerns you may have regarding your condition.